The info of individuals with genetically PCSK9 loss-of-function says in any other case.
Sure it’s, it will increase atherogenic lipoprotein focus, therefore it causes coronary heart illness. You’d have to point out virtually inconceivable proof that it will counter detrimental results from the rise in atherogenic lipoproteins. Mice research can not counter RCT’s and genetic knowledge in people, that might make no sense.
If a fallacious attraction to authority argument goes for use, it needs to be accomplished for an knowledgeable lipidologist like Allan Sniderman or Thomas Dayspring. Not a pediatric endocrinologist. In an earlier video that was linked of Lustig, he actually confused a desk of research with a meta evaluation. The paper which additionally argued in opposition to meta evaluation as a way.
I additionally doubt Joseph understands what apoB is, since Lustig appears to be keen on measuring triglycerides, which apoB additionally measures the lipoprotein focus of.
ASCVD and coronary heart illness and danger is very easy to grasp, simply folks like Lustig desires to be Lustig (It’s Swedish for humorous) and do a reverse Occam’s razor and muddy the waters.
Forgive me. I didn’t notice you had been an MD. If sure then, after all, the research would imply extra to you than to me. If you weren’t a heart specialist, I’d take the views of a pediatric endocrinologist over yours any day of the week.
I believe you missed the half the place I mentioned it was a fallacy.
Arguments and proof stand on their very own two ft.
I discussed Thomas Dayspring and Allan Sniderman.
Should you’re not going to learn any science papers your self, why not take heed to Sniderman as an alternative?
Oh yeah, people are WAY extra susceptible to heart problems than mice, which barely die of it.
ApoB is generally unhealthy when oxidized/glycated – thus reductions in irritation/ROS [with BOTH rapamycin+metformin+taurine+carnosine] ought to cut back a lot of the chance related to elevated lipids.
3 Likes
Quotation wanted, and mechanistic speculations isn’t top quality proof, it’s truly subsequent to the bottom on the proof hierarchy. Till there’s (1) genetic research exhibiting significance of irritation/ROS (2) randomized managed trial of a drug by way of the identical mechanism, then it’s too early to say.
And if that was the case, simply take the drug confirmed in a randomized managed trial.
To gamble on mitigating causal danger with elevated lipoprotein focus by way of different mechanisms, is simply an pointless gamble imo. When there are protected medication to decrease mentioned lipoprotein focus.
Randomized managed trials for heart problems are meaningless. They’re too brief. I may ship you a hyperlink, however why hassle?
As I’ve shamelessly posted many occasions from “Rapamycin for longevity: opinion article” by
Mikhail V. Blagosklonny
“Should you wait till you might be prepared, it’s nearly actually too late.” ~ Seth Godin
2 Likes
No, they set up a baseline which you’ll be able to extrapolate from utilizing genetic research.
And brief time period CVD trials do present helpful results.
However this dialogue is completed as a result of I don’t suppose you’re severe.
Are you utilizing ChatGPT? That paper doesn’t exist.
2 Likes
A pair weeks in the past I used to be doing analysis on Trametinib utilizing ChatGPT and I requested it for educational references. I spent the following hour looking for any of the references it quoted. I couldn’t, they had been all made up.
3 Likes
I had the identical expertise – it makes up papers! Actually makes you surprise about it.
2 Likes
Based on Dr. Lustig and many of the different consultants, avoiding sugar performs a very powerful position in prevention of atherosclerosis and coronary heart illness. Insulin resistance impacts improvement or worsening of hyperlipidemia. Low carb eating regimen might be essentially the most affordable.
1 Like
Sugar solely performs a job in so far as it reduces apoB, the overwhelming majority of apoB is because of saturated fats, so for most individuals a low carb eating regimen can have the other outcome.
apoB measures all atherogenic lipoproteins, together with these with triglycerides.
However it’s doable to have a wholesome low carb eating regimen, changing saturated fats for polyunsaturated or monounsaturated fats. And measuring apoB every so often to ensure issues are (or are going) in the proper course.
Search “LDL” on the keto subreddit for some morbid wednesday studying 
“We nonetheless have LDL denialists on the market”
“It’s one of the crucial harmful issues I see, truly”
I’ve a good friend who did keto and had sky-high apoB. Tbf it was meat-based keto, not MUFA-based keto
Jose Ricon additionally speculated that the rising prevalence of keto might improve coronary heart illness dangers in folks sooner or later
I attempted plant-based keto for like a month and whereas my panels weren’t horrible, they had been nonetheless elevated a bit. Even olives and nuts have SOME saturated fats in them, and the unsaturated fat don’t improve HDL that a lot (HDL appears extra genetically decided)
